Key Words: Video games, laparoscopic skills, Epistemonikos, GRADE.
INTRODUCTION
The use of video games has been proposed as an alternative to shorten the learning curve of basic laparoscopic skills. However, it is not yet clar how useful this practice is.
METHODS
We searched in Epistemonikos, the largest database of systematic reviews in health, which is maintained by screening multiple information sources, including MEDLINE, EMBASE, Cochrane, among others. We extracted data from the systematic reviews, reanalyzed data of primary studies, conducted a meta-analysis and generated a summary of findings table using the GRADE approach.
RESULTS AND CONCLUSIONS
We identified three systematic reviews including eight primary studies, of which four were randomized trials. We concluded video games training could help shorten the learning curve of basic laparoscopic visuospatial skills measured in a virtual platform, but the certainty of the available evidence is low.
Both reduced training time with living patients and rapid technological progress have changed surgical training in recent years. New forms of training have been implemented, such as of simulators or virtual reality exercises, especially in the field of minimally invasive surgery. The practice of video games could help acquire surgical skills, since it involves fine motor skills and familiarity with the use of 2D images to represent 3D realities. The possibility of training these skills through video games provides a new alternative for improvement. Despite the enthusiasm generated by these new tools, the evidence supporting its actual efficacy is a matter of debate.
We searched in Epistemonikos, the largest database of systematic reviews in health, which is maintained by screening multiple information sources, including MEDLINE, EMBASE, Cochrane, among others, to identify systematic reviews and their included primary studies. We extracted data from the identified reviews and reanalyzed data from primary studies included in those reviews. With this information, we generated a structured summary denominated FRISBEE (Friendly Summary of Body of Evidence using Epistemonikos) using a pre-established format, which includes key messages, a summary of the body of evidence (presented as an evidence matrix in Epistemonikos), meta-analysis of the total of studies when it is possible, a summary of findings table following the GRADE approach and a table of other considerations for decision-making.
Key messages
|
What is the evidence. |
We found three systematic reviews [1],[2],[3] that included eight primary studies [4],[5],[6],[7],[8],[9],[10],[11], of which four were randomized trials [4],[5],[6],[7]. This table and the summary in general are based on the latter, since observational studies, even though reinforcing the positive association between use of video games and performance in basic laparoscopic skills, did not increase the certainty of the existing evidence. We only included systematic reviews evaluating mass-market consoles such as Nintendo Wii, Playstation or XBox. Thus, other video game formats such as virtual reality simulators or other virtual models were excluded. |
What types of participants were included* |
The trials included medical students without experience in laparoscopic surgery [5],[6] and novice residents of surgery [4],[7]. |
What types of interventions were included* |
The type of intervention used in all trials consisted of training with popular video games for a certain period of time. Three trials [4],[6],[7] measured the acquisition of basic laparoscopic skills with video games using a laparoscopic simulator and one trial [5] used an animal model. The average duration of game sessions was of 25-30 minutes per day. All trials compared against non-use of video games as a form of training, so in that period the control group did not practice with any method. |
What types of outcomes |
Each trial used a different method for measuring basic laparoscopic skills pre- and post-training with video games, both in virtual simulators or in animal models. In the different trials, follow-up was one [6], two [5], or five weeks [4],[7]. |
* The information about primary studies is extracted from the systematic reviews identified, unless otherwise specified.
The information on the effect of video games as training for basic laparoscopic surgical skills is based on four randomized trials involving 99 surgeons or students [4],[5],[6],[7].
All trials reported laparoscopic skills, but none of the reviews presented data that could be re-analyzed or pooled in a meta-analysis, so the conclusions are presented as they were reported by the systematic reviews identified.
The summary of findings is as follows:
Follow the link to access the interactive version of this table (Interactive Summary of Findings – iSoF) |
To whom this evidence does and does not apply |
|
About the outcomes included in this summary |
|
Balance between benefits and risks, and certainty of the evidence |
|
Resource considerations |
|
What would patients and their doctors think about this intervention |
|
Differences between this summary and other sources |
|
Could this evidence change in the future? |
|
Using automated and collaborative means, we compiled all the relevant evidence for the question of interest and we present it as a matrix of evidence.
Follow the link to access the interactive version: Video games as a method of training basic laparoscopic skills.
The upper portion of the matrix of evidence will display a warning of “new evidence” if new systematic reviews are published after the publication of this summary. Even though the project considers the periodical update of these summaries, users are invited to comment in Medwave or to contact the authors through email if they find new evidence and the summary should be updated earlier.
After creating an account in Epistemonikos, users will be able to save the matrixes and to receive automated notifications any time new evidence potentially relevant for the question appears.
This article is part of the Epistemonikos Evidence Synthesis project. It is elaborated with a pre-established methodology, following rigorous methodological standards and internal peer review process. Each of these articles corresponds to a summary, denominated FRISBEE (Friendly Summary of Body of Evidence using Epistemonikos), whose main objective is to synthesize the body of evidence for a specific question, with a friendly format to clinical professionals. Its main resources are based on the evidence matrix of Epistemonikos and analysis of results using GRADE methodology. Further details of the methods for developing this FRISBEE are described here (http://dx.doi.org/10.5867/medwave.2014.06.5997)
Epistemonikos foundation is a non-for-profit organization aiming to bring information closer to health decision-makers with technology. Its main development is Epistemonikos database (www.epistemonikos.org).
Potential conflicts of interest
The authors do not have relevant interests to declare.
INTRODUCCIÓN
El uso de videojuegos ha sido propuesto como alternativa para acortar la curva de aprendizaje de las habilidades laparoscópicas básicas. Sin embargo, aún no está clara su real utilidad.
MÉTODOS
Realizamos una búsqueda en Epistemonikos, la mayor base de datos de revisiones sistemáticas en salud, la cual es mantenida mediante el cribado de múltiples fuentes de información, incluyendo MEDLINE, EMBASE, Cochrane, entre otras. Extrajimos los datos desde las revisiones identificadas, analizamos los datos de los estudios primarios, realizamos un metanálisis y preparamos una tabla de resumen de los resultados utilizando el método GRADE.
RESULTADOS Y CONCLUSIONES
Se identificaron tres revisiones sistemáticas que en conjunto incluyeron ocho estudios primarios, de los cuales cuatro son ensayos aleatorizados. Se concluyó que el entrenamiento mediante el uso de videojuegos podría ayudar a acortar la curva de aprendizaje de habilidades visuoespaciales laparoscópicas básicas medido en una plataforma virtual, sin embargo la certeza de la evidencia disponible es baja.
Citation: Domínguez JI, Ramos A, Achurra P. Video games as a method of training basic laparoscopic skills. Medwave 2018;18(7):e7344 doi: 10.5867/medwave.2018.07.7344
Submission date: 8/4/2018
Acceptance date: 12/11/2018
Publication date: 23/11/2018
Origin: This article is a product of the Evidence Synthesis Project of Epistemonikos Fundation, in collaboration with Medwave for its publication.
Type of review: Non-blinded peer review by members of the methodological team of Epistemonikos Evidence Synthesis Project.
We are pleased to have your comment on one of our articles. Your comment will be published as soon as it is posted. However, Medwave reserves the right to remove it later if the editors consider your comment to be: offensive in some sense, irrelevant, trivial, contains grammatical mistakes, contains political harangues, appears to be advertising, contains data from a particular person or suggests the need for changes in practice in terms of diagnostic, preventive or therapeutic interventions, if that evidence has not previously been published in a peer-reviewed journal.
No comments on this article.
To comment please log in